Name a dish/beverage combination that sounds like it would be horrible, but in reality is really good

[Rod]

Cold spaghetti and mayo sandwich. Peanut butter (or peanut butter based sauce) on a burger.

[WillTravelForFood]

We sense a trend with these Mayo combinations.

Does the fact that the spaghetti is cold make a difference vs a hot spaghetti + mayo combo?

[Rod]

WillTravelForFood Never tried it with hot spaghetti.

[tmelosi]

Bacon + almost anything

[texastweeter]

Raw dry cured bacon and watermelon
beer and chocolate cake
cheddar cheese and peanutbutter

[DavidNorcross]

Cold pizza. Liver and onions.

[HawkerXP]

Liver, onions and BACON! Oh yeah!

[HawkerXP]

We just had this tonight!

[58limited]

I eat cold pizza all the time!

[Oak Smoke]

Mashed potatoes and ketchup, a peanut butter banana and mayo sandwich. Pastrami fried like bacon with eggs and hash browns for breakfast.

[WillTravelForFood]

Banana + Mayo definitely has a bit of cringe factor at the suggestion

[smokenoob]

French Fries & Dukes Mayo FTW!

[smokenoob]

Mr. Bones Who could turn that gourmet combo down, only the unsophisticated!

[WillTravelForFood]

Curious why that sounds like a horrible idea?

[STEbbq]

I see no problem with this one. Yum.

[RustyHaines]

Bourbon on the rocks with 4 jalapeno stuffed olives. I drink this occasionally (using non-premium bourbon of course) as a detour from my usual bourbon on the rocks.

[Thunder77]

Hamburger with Thai sweet chili sauce. My new favorite!

[SheilaAnn]

Thunder77 do you mean a burger burger? A place I used to work at did a chicken sandwich with sweet chili Mayo and thai basil. So good……

[GolfGeezer]

Gefilte fish and red horseradish. An acquired taste, but it was a great way to always have something in the frig that my roommates wouldn't eat.

[TripleB]

This is one of the more unique combos I seen here. I’d try it, but not buy it.

[Dr. Pepper]

A regular pesach dish. Took my gentile wife a while to appreciate it, however.

[SmokeyGator]

IPA and Stout. Normally I like one or the other, but nothing at all is wrong with a black and tan!

[tamidw]

Skrewball Peanut Butter whisky and cocoa cow stout beer tastes pretty darn good together!

[FireMan]

Once had a friend make a pumpkin pie with cloves of garlic in it. It didn’t work, nosirree.

[bmillin]

Sandwich with peanut butter and a slice of red onion

[WillTravelForFood]

oooof, no.

[JoeSousa]

One of the tastiest things I have made is a Cadbury Creme Scotch Egg. Wrap a Cadbury Creme egg in ground breakfast sausage, coat it in an egg wash and panko, and then deep fry. The overly sweet creme egg plays very nicely with the salty, spicy sausage.

[Caffeine88]

I..... Uh..... Nope. Nope, can't see it!

[fzxdoc]

One Peanut M&M nestled into the scoop of a piece Frito's Scoops.

Kathryn

[Mr. Bones]

Melted, or no?

[smokenoob]

somehow I can taste that right now 😳
if I could connect my taste buds to my imagination, I could loose weight 🤔

[fzxdoc]

Not melted, Mr. Bones. The Peanut M&M just rolls around in the Scoop's scoop.

K.

[58limited]

Hot links (split and fried in a skillet with butter) served with Miracle Whip. I grew up with this and I like it but I can see that it sounds nasty to those who haven't had it.