Instagram AmazingRibs Facebook AmazingRibs X - Meathead Pinterest AmazingRibs Youtube AmazingRibs

Welcome!


This is a membership forum. Guests can view 5 pages for free. To participate, please join.

[ Pitmaster Club Information | Join Now | 30 Day Trial | Login | Contact Us ]

Only 4 free page views remaining.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Question about healthier grilling...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Question about healthier grilling...

    Hey, everyone. I've just had a moment that sort of threw me for a loop, and could really use help figuring out the next step.

    It happened while I was standing over the kettle grilling some chicken. I've been making a lot lately, in a bid to boost the protein in my diet lately (not throwing shade on protein shakes, I just prefer to eat my calories). Very recently I've been mixing up the way I've been cooking, going from grill-smoking a bird whole to breaking it down and grilling the pieces - allows me to prep and cook much quicker.

    Anyway, I brought it in, let it cool a bit and was pulling the skin off to shred the meat, when it struck me: since I moved to a warmer climate about a year ago, I've been grilling probably every other day, sometimes a few days in a row. In addition to the weather, we haven't had a working oven in the house so almost everything gets grilled. I really like the situation generally speaking as I prefer grilling to just about every other method of cooking (I'm a card carrying AR member after all). Then it struck me how much charcoal I've been using lately, which got me thinking about what I might be doing to myself longer term eating charcoal cooked food 5 times a week.

    We are moving later this year into a new place, and for that one I'd been planning on building a new setup with perhaps an LSG so I could grill and smoke on one unit. That's a major commitment and, in light of this conundrum, I'm really not sure I should do that now. I haven't had a gas grill in ages, but maybe I need to think about that seriously as the main cooker and use charcoal more sparingly now that I'll be cooking outside so often.

    I've done some basic research and read that cooking indirect, avoiding charred meat and even marinating in citrus can reduce carcinogens from forming. Anybody know the validity of these claims? While we're at it, am I just being paranoid? I mean, I'd like to live a long and healthy life, but I'm not steaming my food for the rest of it just to get an extra year on the end. That said, if grilling over gas were substantially healthier than charcoal grilling (all other things equal of course), I could certainly be swayed to change my ways and bring out the charcoal or smoker for special occasions only.

    Thanks for reading! Any thoughts, advice etc. would be really appreciated.

    Cheers

    #2
    I've got a very (very) long answer on health and food in general, but when it comes to grilling, I believe Meathead has answered that question in depth: https://amazingribs.com/more-techniq...e-cancer-risk/

    Comment


    • Mister C
      Mister C commented
      Editing a comment
      Man, talk about things being right under your nose. Thanks for this! Probably the first thing I should have done was check this very site, and yet I was off in the weeds of the internet. So informative, thanks again to Meathead for such a thoughtful examination of the subject and to you for highlighting it. 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

    • dpearce
      dpearce commented
      Editing a comment
      Mister C Meathead is a surprisingly well researched individual. I almost hate to start a new topic here unless I scour the site first!

    • Meathead
      Meathead commented
      Editing a comment
      Thanks for the kind words. Old school journalism major who tries to report facts and checks them out.

    #3
    So, based upon no research or knowledge, I would go with a gas grill and a charcoal or pellet cooker.
    Everything in moderation, nothing to excess.

    Comment


    • Mister C
      Mister C commented
      Editing a comment
      Fair enough, and thanks. This whole episode has tilted my perspective towards incorporating at least some kind of propane cooking. Whether it becomes the primary cooker remains to be seen.

    • yakima
      yakima commented
      Editing a comment
      One consideration is what fuel is readily available at your location.
      A gas grill with a griddle on the grate also makes a passable substitute for a griddle/flat top.

    • Mister C
      Mister C commented
      Editing a comment
      You know yakima, I have a little tabletop blackstone that I was using for griddle stuff, but this might be a great idea to consolidate functions a little. Thanks for that

    #4
    Y’all beat me to it! +100

    Comment


      #5
      I will continue to grill and smoke using charcoal.
      No use living longer if you cannot enjoy the food.

      Comment


      • Mister C
        Mister C commented
        Editing a comment
        Amen to that. Thanks

      #6
      I’m 73 years old, I’ve had a couple of health issues but they were very fixable. I can’t find anything in the few issues I’ve had that relates to grilling and smoking. I’m currently in the care of three doctors. I’m on an I’ll see you in 6 months schedule with all of them. I take 2 pills for blood pressure daily, that’s it. I grill and smoke regularly. I believe that until recently all cooking was done over live fire or hot coals. You don’t have to char it to cook it but I love the flavor of a bit of char. As I watch friends get sick I can’t attribute any of it to grilled or smoked food. The abuse of alcohol, tobacco, obesity, and just bad genetics are what’s taking them away. Not grilled food. Worry will get you before grilling will IMHO. The only gas grill i currently have is a commercial char griller. I think you should go with the heat source you enjoy most.

      Comment


      • Mister C
        Mister C commented
        Editing a comment
        Thanks, I appreciate you sharing all that. I do love the taste of charcoal or wood.

      • cruiseplanner1
        cruiseplanner1 commented
        Editing a comment
        Wow sounds so similar to myself. 70 2 blood pressure meds. And we grill almost daily when the weather allows us here. Also smoke cigars which surprisingly my MD and cardiologist did not complain about. The food tastes so much better when cooked over a grill and more so if charcoal if time allots it.

      #7
      I couldn't get thru the post. If the question is what is best for you? I use charcoal, smoke via wood. And all the on PBJ, Kettle with SnS and Vortex, the gasser with pellets or wood chips in smoke box or pellet pipe. I'm 73. Still kicking it. No adverse impact to my cooking method. If you're concerned, there are other techniques to cook. Airfryed, and Panhead John favorite, boiled ribs. Seriously, I'd loosen up. But if it's a concern for you and your family, find another way.

      Comment


      • bbqLuv
        bbqLuv commented
        Editing a comment
        Boiled ribs in beer for the win. Here is the technique for country style ribs:
        1. place in pot,
        2. cover with beer,
        3. slowly bring to a boil,
        4. finish on grill.

        Then I got introduced to pellet grilling and never looked back. About 7 years ago I took up BBQ and smoking as a hobby.

      • bbqLuv
        bbqLuv commented
        Editing a comment
        Actually, when you boil ribs, pork steak, etc. it helps to remove fat.
        Don't worry about flavor that is with BBQ sauce is for.
        Better the sauce, better the Q. 😁

      • Mister C
        Mister C commented
        Editing a comment
        Originally posted by RichieB View Post
        I couldn't get thru the post. If the question is what is best for you?
        Yeah, like I said I was having a moment. Never really thought about cooking everyday over live fire and possible negative effects vs. less smoky methods of cooking. Freaked me out a little, but thanks to you and everyone else for bringing me back.

        As for this ribs sidenote, I'm reminded of my favorite Meathead -ism: "When you boil ribs, the terrorists win." 😂

      #8
      Every human who drank water or milk has eventually died. As always, YMMV

      Comment


        #9
        Man. I get where you’re coming from.

        On the other hand, you can get all caught up asking those questions about everything.

        Ask yourself: “What creates the best sense of balance, FOR ME?” Then answer the question honestly. At the extremes, you’ll have on one hand the live fast/die young crowd and on the other the austere, pure living, teetotalers. (But even within those, you’ll have Keith Richards and Jim Fixx [wrote The Compete Book of Running, died of a heart attack while out jogging]….) Within those extremes, each of us will find the spot that gives us comfort. On a simple matter like charcoal/propane: do you like the way the food tastes more than you fear the risk… or, otherwise stated: is the improvement in your quality of life enough that it doesn’t matter? Then do what makes you happy.



        Comment


        • Ace
          Ace commented
          Editing a comment
          +1 True that... 👍

        • Mister C
          Mister C commented
          Editing a comment
          Well said, thanks. BTW you can add Angus Young to the teetotaler list.

        #10
        I’m totally unqualified to answer this scientifically/medically. That said, anyone can be a philosopher 😬😬. Here goes: I believe it’s incredibly important to enjoy all the little pleasures that come your way - a grilled chicken, a hot shower, a glass of wine. I’ve found that happiness can be defined as the quality of your life minus envy. The less I care what someone else has or does and the more grateful I am for all the little things in my life, the happier I am. So eat (in moderation) what you love and give up measuring winning in life by how long you live.

        Thus ends the sermon.
        Last edited by JCBBQ; February 14, 2026, 09:25 AM.

        Comment


        • Mister C
          Mister C commented
          Editing a comment
          Thanks for that and well said. It's not really length of life I think too much of as much as quality. Had a lot of family that went the slow, suffering way out. Obviously it's colored my perspective.

        • Finster
          Finster commented
          Editing a comment
          Well stated. Now, if I could only get my doctor to agree with my definition of moderation 😂

        • JCBBQ
          JCBBQ commented
          Editing a comment
          Finster lol

        #11
        My philosophy is that I will be better off enjoying my life rather than worrying about what “the latest science” says.
        No telling how much damage was done to Americans when “science” said that everyone should stop eating butter and use margarine or some other chemical concoction that tries but fails to mimic butter. Now butter is back on the table as that margarine “science” was disproved. (No offense intended towards real scientists who aren’t hacks paid by government or corporations.)

        Comment


        • JCBBQ
          JCBBQ commented
          Editing a comment
          💯 yes

        • Mister C
          Mister C commented
          Editing a comment
          Margarine, what a great example. Thanks for your thoughts.

        #12
        A single female friend of mine said, "...Life is too short to dance with ugly men..."

        Comment


        • Mister C
          Mister C commented
          Editing a comment
          Well put, and strangely very apt. 😂

        • jayjordan
          jayjordan commented
          Editing a comment
          Funny…unless she said it over her shoulder as she walked away from your request.

        • klflowers
          klflowers commented
          Editing a comment
          That’s why I haven’t danced in years???

        #13
        If I can't eat what I like, hunt ducks, catch fish, and blow up clay targets with shotguns, then dig the flipping hole. 'Nough said. 🥰

        Comment


        • texastweeter
          texastweeter commented
          Editing a comment
          PREACH!!!

        #14
        Thanks to everyone for the comments! I needed a little grounding after that moment and you all really provided that, with thoughtfulness and humor as always.

        After a little thinking, I do think I'll look at incorporating at least a little gas grill if for nothing else than the advantages of convenience and cleanup. At the same time, I'll definitely be keeping charcoal as a prominent if not the primary cooking method.

        I have precious few people in my life with the experience to answer a question like this, so thanks again to all. I'm really grateful to everyone in this community for making it a fun and interesting place to be part of. Cheers everybody

        Comment


        • Mosca
          Mosca commented
          Editing a comment
          I liked having a gasser. But when I got the griddle, the gasser dropped out of rotation. The gasser was best at burgers and dogs. But the griddle just outright thumps it for burgers, and if I’m only making dogs I’ll fire up the Smokey Joe or section off the Kettle with the S&S.

          I got the gasser for free (saved it from the dumpster, changed out the regulator and gave it a good cleaning), so I gave it away for equally free; didn’t want to disrupt the karma of that one.

        • Mister C
          Mister C commented
          Editing a comment
          Mosca yeah I have a little Blackstone griddle and love it as well. yakima suggested a griddle on a gas grill which may end up being the best of both worlds for me.

        • RichieB
          RichieB commented
          Editing a comment
          I have a Spirit 3 burner and the full insert griddle, carbon steel. Room was the reason why the went with the insert. I'm not disappointed.

        #15
        Cold beer, bourbon, cigars. Charcoal danger is way down the list

        Comment


        • texastweeter
          texastweeter commented
          Editing a comment
          You beat me to my below comment

      Announcement

      Collapse
      No announcement yet.
      Working...
      X
      false
      0
      Guest
      Guest
      500
      ["membership","help","nojs","maintenance","shop","reset-password","authaau-alpha","ebooklogin-start","alpha","start"]
      false
      false
      Yes
      ["\/forum\/free-deep-dive-guide-ebook-downloads","\/forum\/free-deep-dive-guide-ebook-downloads\/1157845-paid-members-download-your-6-deep-dive-guide-ebooks-for-free-here","\/forum\/the-pitcast","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/bbq-news-magazine-2019-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/bbq-news-magazine-2020-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/bbq-news-magazine-2021-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/bbq-news-magazine-2022-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/current-2023-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/current-2024-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/current-2025-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/current-2026-issues","\/forum\/bbq-stars","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/tuffy-stone","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/meathead","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/harry-soo","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/matt-pittman","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/kent-rollins","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/dean-fearing","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/tim-grandinetti","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/kent-phillips-brett-gallaway","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/david-bouska","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/ariane-daguin","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/jack-arnold","\/forum\/free-deep-dive-guide-ebook-downloads"]
      /forum/free-deep-dive-guide-ebook-downloads