THE Critical Hot Dog Question

[Dr. Pepper]

Boy, all the hot dog threads going today!! ðŸŒ

[Attjack]

I'll take credit for this.

[scottranda]

Same 😃

[Draznnl]

As if ketchup on a hot dog wasn't stomach turning enough, mayo? MAYO? MAYO!? Is this just some sick joke? I can't believe y'all are serious. Like Nancy Reagan used to say, "Just say no."

[Attjack]

I think you have misunderstood. The mayo replaces the ketchup thus solving 2 problems. A crappy condiment is vanquished and the best condiment is enlisted to accentuate the flavor of the dog.

[Dan Deter]

SWMBO does, but I love her anyway.

[Sid P]

I’ll answer this in the form of a riddle.

I do two of these regularly, and one is just the craziest thing I’ve ever heard. Which one is crazy?

1) Eat a peanut butter and onion sandwich.
2) Put lots of pepper on my cantaloupe.
3) Put mayonnaise on a hot dog.

[Attjack]

#1 is pretty damn nuts

[Sid P]

Attjack I know from your hot dog thread that you’re willing to experiment, so give it a try. If you like both onions and peanut butter, you’ll love them together.

[Attjack]

I've had PB on a burger so I could fathom it.

[Richard Chrz]

This one time at Band camp…

[Panhead John]

Continue……

[Panhead John]

This makes me kinda miss the "salt" threads from last month.

[CaptainMike]

Duke's mayo, maybe, but I wouldn't tell anyone and I'd eat it out in the woods where no one could see me.

[STEbbq]

Check out my posts on Dutch Mayo for recipes.

[CaptainMike]

Richard Chrz Troutman calls it unicorn snot. After trying it on that recommendation a few years ago I have to agree. Order direct from them, they are a great company to work with.

[barelfly]

Ha! So…no miracle whip?

…….>>>>>>>>>>>>>Runs out the door quickly…..

[HawkerXP]

No.

[kjbarth]

No sir!

[tbob4]

Mayo 100% of the time at home. 90% of the time I add - pico heavy in jalapeños and cheese. Ketchup with hot sauce is a must, as well. Sometimes sweet relish if the pico is strong. Dogs must be 1/4 pound.

If I am at a ballpark I go traditional with ketchup, mustard, relish and a lot of onions - no Mayo.

[Red Man]

I’ll never put mayo on a hot dog. Mayo is my most hated condiment. I can stand it mixed in to some things as an ingredient but never on its own.

[Attjack]

You spelled "ketchup" wrong.

[Santamarina]

It’s not a given - like mustard - but it’s a frequent addition…unlike ketchup, which is never added!

[Mosca]

California style. Grilled to a light char, with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, mayo.

[saneric38]

I add mayo (in particular, Hellmann's)

[Strat50]

I do, occasionally, use mayo, but how much will depend on the other condiments present. Richer tasting mayo's like Kewpie, are my choice. Homemade is the best for me, as I usually have some in the fridge.