I’ve been on this quest for a while. I’ve even discussed it here before but there are some really good cooks among us now that might have an idea. I love Arby’s roast beef sandwiches. I don’t want sauce or anything else on them just the roast beef. We were in Waco Tx Wednesday. That gave me the rare chance to go by an Arby’s. I got the half pound roast beef sandwich and loved every bite of it! Arby’s and Burger King are dying out here. It’s only a matter of time until I won’t be able to get that sandwich I love. Here’s what I want to know. What would you season a roast with and how would you cook it at home to get as close as possible to the Arby’s taste? I have a nice slicer so all I need is the taste.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Arby’s roast beef
Collapse
X
-
- Likes 6
-
I'd try a top round roast with simple seasoning like salt, black pepper, garlic powder, and onion powder. Slow-roast it, chill overnight, and slice it very thin. That should get you pretty close to the classic Arby's roast beef taste!
By the way, since you mentioned loving Arby's Half Pound Roast Beef, I found this guide that covers their different roast beef sandwiches, including prices and calories. It might be useful to compare the options:
- 1 like
-
Club Member
- Dec 2018
- 6376
- Texas Gulf Coast
-
Grills:
Weber 22" Kettle Premium w/Slow N' Sear 2.0
Pit Barrel Cooker
Grilla Grills Chimp
W.C. Bradley & Co. Char Kettle CK-115 ~1980s Vintage Grill (inactive)
What Donw and Troutman said: Baltimore Pit Beef. I even have a roast in the freezer that is earmarked for this. I do it super-traditional.....just salt and pepper and char the heck out of the exterior.
The secret for me is to really dry-brine the beef for two days. You'll be shocked at how flavorful something is that is just seasoned with salt and pepper.
I'm still working on a good horseradish sauce. Mine always seem to come out a hair too bitter.
- Likes 4
Comment
-
Michael_in_TX I do not care for horseradish in the application…..BUT, to SundaySmokeSignal below about prepared horseradish. Have you tried fresh grated? I worked at a place that was locally famous for its Prime Rib. PSA: wear swimming goggles. You think old onions make you “cry”…….
- 2 likes
-
SheilaAnn I have, sorta. I once sourced some real wasabi (I was trying to be "authentic") and that was an experience. Food is not supposed to hurt like that....especially before you even eat it!!
- 2 likes
-
I just posted the ingredients for the Arby's roast beef that I got from their site. It is water, salt and sodium phosphates. So, if they aren't lying, their roast beef is just brined beef that is cooked for several hours in a bag of marinade.
- 1 like
-
Club Member
- Nov 2017
- 8792
- Huntsville, Alabama
-
Jim Morris
Cookers- PBX (2026)
- Slow 'N Sear Deluxe Kamado (2021)
- Camp Chef FTG900 Flat Top Grill (2020)
- Weber Genesis II E-410 w/ GrillGrates (2019)
- Weber Performer Deluxe 22.5" w/ GrillGrates & Slow 'N Sear & Drip N Griddle & Vortex & Party Q & Rotisserie (2007)
- Thermoworks RFX System w/ 2 probes + Billows
- Thermoworks Smoke w/ Wifi Gateway
- Thermoworks Dot
- Thermoworks Thermapen ONE & Classic
- Thermoworks RT600C
- Whatever I brewed and have on tap! See it here: https://taplist.io/taplist-57685
- If not cooking outdoors, I am cooking on the stovetop with my 14" carbon steel wok, 12" CI skillet, or in the oven with my two Lodge CI pizza pans, or two dutch ovens. I've also got a nifty Lodge carbon steel grill pan that rocks for veggies outdoors.
I am with Oak Smoke on liking Arby's roast beef. That and a jamocha shake and I'm happy!
I need to do this. It would finally give me an excuse to get a top/bottom round roast. And something to use the deli slicer for! And I wonder... would the rotisserie spit be a good way to make this? Or just stay indirect with a reverse sear as the recipe calls for?
Wife does not like pink, but would have to live with it for this to be good. It might just get turned into a pile of roast beef for me to save and eat for lunches...
EDIT: I had an Arby's about 3/4 mile from the house, that opened not more than 5 years ago. Imagine my surprise when I stopped there a month or so back, and the signage was removed from the drive through that I had been through 1 week earlier, with a paper notice saying to visit another location about 3 miles away!
In front of the same BUSY shopping center on the same 4 lane road a Wendy's closed several months before that, a Sonic 6 months earlier as well, leaving just Zaxby's as the only drive through. That said - I usually went to Arby's because Zaxby's next to it always had a longer drive-through line. Which is probably why they are still in business... That said, Sonic was completely and utterly mismanaged and poorly staffed, and had sucked for years.
But... they just opened up a "Waldo's Chicken and Beer" right around the corner from these closed places. Gotta check that one out, haha.
Last edited by jfmorris; November 6, 2026, 03:07 PM.
- Likes 2
Comment
-
Haha. Yes it has a drive through, but I'll bet they are CONSTANTLY having to tell folks they cannot sell beer to go. It's not legal in Alabama....
Not for a restaurant anyway.
I've got to check it out. Has friend chicken and rotisserie chicken, both supposedly marinated overnight in some kind of pickle juice brine.
-
Oak, the Baltimore Pit Beef direction Donw and Troutman pointed to is the right one for that flavor, and a top or bottom round roast is the cut to use. Dry brine it for 2 days like Michael_in_TX said, 1/2 teaspoon of kosher salt per pound, then a heavy coat of coarse black pepper, garlic powder, and onion powder right before the cook. Cook it indirect at 225 to 250F until the center hits 120 to 125F for rare, then sear it hard over direct heat for 2 to 3 minutes a side to get the char. Rest it 20 minutes, chill it a little if you want truly thin slices, and slice it as thin as your slicer will go, against the grain. That thin slice is half the Arby's texture. For jfmorris, a rotisserie works well here too, same 225 to 250F target and same 120 to 125F pull, and it gives a very even crust, but indirect with a reverse sear is simpler and just as good. If pink is a problem at home, pull at 135F for medium, it will still be tender if it is sliced thin, but it will not taste quite like the original. On the horseradish sauce, Michael, the bitterness usually comes from too much fresh grated horseradish or from using the vinegar-packed kind straight. Try 1/4 cup sour cream, 2 tablespoons mayonnaise, 1 tablespoon prepared horseradish, 1 teaspoon lemon juice, and a pinch of sugar and salt, then let it sit 30 minutes and taste before adding more horseradish.
- Likes 7
Comment
-
SundaySmokeSignal Sounds like a plan for that horseradish! Thank you!
- 2 likes
-
Thanks for the great suggestions! Hope you decide to join as a full member of The Pit!
- 2 likes
-
Club Member
- Dec 2015
- 4544
- Northeastern Oklahoma
-
Traeger BBQ124 (in storage)
Yoder YS480
No gas grill anymore
Weber kettle Premium 22"
Blackstone 36" griddle
Camp Chef Smoke Vault 24 propane smoker
Super 55 drum smoker from Smokerbuilder.com
"The Duk" Ugly Duckling self-built 80-gallon insulated firebox backyard offset smoker
"Big Bertha" 320-gallon trailer mounted offset smoker (also self-built)
"The Bronco" 26x48 110-gallon trailer mounted offset smoker (currently for sale!)
Numerous electronic thermometers from Thermapro, Thermoworks and Fireboard.
Personal firearms, home theater, home computing/networking, car audio enthusiast. Smoker building.
Mrs. O'Leary's Cow CrustOriginally posted by Oak Smoke View PostOk I went to try to put this together. I can’t find the cow crust recipe on the site anywhere. Any ideas?
Packed with seasonings and blended with oil, this wet paste adds to the flavor of your bark and takes grilled or smoked meat over the top.
- Likes 2
Comment
-
Club Member
- May 2023
- 1171
- Inland Empire, CA
-
Grilla OG Pellet Cooker 🦍
Grand Prize Weiner: Blaze 3 Burner LP Grill 🙂
From the Arby's ingredient list:
Roast Beef: Beef, Water, Salt, Sodium Phosphates.
I have no clue how much Sodium Phosphates affect the taste.
There is an article on Chowhound on how they cook the beef, it is done in a bag with a marinade, which I guess is water, salt and sodium phosphates maybe.🤷♀️ The beef arrives at the restaurant in bags, so I have no clue how long the beef sits in the marinade. Anyway, maybe that will help you figure it out. I would think the method is necessary because the beef is served well done. Looks well done anyway. 🤷♀️
I like their roast beef too and always wondered how it was cooked.
Last edited by Carolyn; November 7, 2026, 03:53 PM.
- Likes 1
Comment
-
Club Member
- Dec 2018
- 5580
- SE Texas
-
"Beer is proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy." ~Benjamin Franklin
Oak Smoke I really like Arby's Beef and Cheddar sandwich - without the red sauce which is some sort of salad dressing, I like it with the Arby's sauce though. Arby's used to have potato cakes: kind of a thick triangular hash brown, been disappointed ever since they discontinued them 20 some years ago. They were great dipped in the Arby's sauce.
The first time I had a true Baltimore pit beef sandwich at Pioneer Pit Beef I realized what Arby's is trying to do but can never achieve in a mass produced fast food setting. I have made pit beef a few times now, once with a bison roast, and it has been great each time. Gotta have that Tiger Sauce!
- Likes 3
Comment
-
@59limited They recently brought back the potato cakes.
I was really disappointed when I went there for the first time in years, and fries were being served. I didn't want to go back, but they brought them back for some dish that uses them, so they are back on the menu, which made me very happy.
- 2 likes
-
Now for the first time in ages I want an Arby’s roast beef sandwich. There was an Arby’s down the street from my office in St. Louis I used to go to often. That location and a nearby Wendy’s both closed, reducing the number of lunch options near the office.
Fortunately there are three Arby’s locations near me so next week I will have a roast beef sandwich.
- Likes 5
Comment
-
Just finished an Arby’s Double Roast Beef sandwich and curly fries. Was good, a break from burgers and chicken sandwiches.
- Likes 4
Comment
-
Went there yesterday coming back with my son and my two grandsons. They always stop there on the way back and I have not been for some years now. Ordered a Turkey Club but that was unimpressive. Wish I would have gone with my years ago fave the Beef and Cheddar. Kids 4 and 7 had sliders, curly fries and a chocolate shake. They were enjoying it.
- 2 likes
-
Oak Smoke concur about curly fries. I'm just not a fan.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.







Comment