I’ve tried 3 from the list. Typically, I mix up my own version of Meatheads MMD and BBBR, but it is nice to have a couple of commercial rubs available in a pinch. Kinder’s Prime Steak is one that I will never be without for steaks!!!! Use a little or a lot, it is absolutely perfect on steaks for me!!!!
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Best BBQ Rubs? Top 20
Collapse
X
-
Club Member
- Jul 2016
- 904
- Brownsburg, Indiana
-
Cookers:
Oklahoma Joe Offset (older thick steel version!)
Camp Chef Woodwind
OK Joe Bronco
Weber Genesis
Ooni Karu
Weber Kettle
Blackstone 36”
My goal is to eventually have at least one of every style of cooker….. I have work to do. Lol!
Thermometers:
ThermoWorks Thermapen MK4
ThermoWorks Thermapen ONE
ThermoWorks Thermopop
ThermoWorks RFX
ThermoWorks IRK-2 Infrared
Maverick XR-50
TempSpike Plus
Other Gear:
Megaforce 3000 Meat Grinder
Weston 7-pound sausage stuffer
Jerky Gun for making poppers. (Game changer!)
Amaz-N-Tube
Original SnS with drip n griddle
Weber Chimney
Fuels Used:
Splits/Chunks, whatever I can get. Usually B&B competition. Favorites are Cherry, Apple, Post Oak, and Hickory.
Pellets, Lumberjack or Smokin’ Pecan
Charcoal, whatever is on sale. Currently have a bunch of KBB. Will eventually try B&B. Use whatever lump is on sale in my Ooni.
Propane, Blue Rhino.
Rubs:
Usually make my own riff’s on Memphis Dust and BBBR. Also use Meathead’s commercial rubs and occasionally try something new. I like a couple from Tuffy Stone and Kinder’s. After several surgeries, I’m very sensitive to “spicy” stuff, so I need to be careful about heat levels.
-
I had so many commercial rubs that I gave most of them away here a couple of years ago. When it comes to bought rubs I only have Meat Church fajita and Salt Grass 7 steak spice. I make all the rest. Most of what I do is covered by my steak rub, MMD, SPG, and Lawry’s seasoned salt. Simple can be very good!
- Likes 4
Comment
-
For a general purpose list from the rubs I have compared in guides and reviews, I would start with these, by use case, not just brand hype:
Pork ribs and pork butt: Killer Hogs The BBQ Rub is the one I see recommended most for pork, it is sweet, salty, and paprika forward, and it works well at 225 to 250 degrees for a long cook. Meat Church Holy Gospel is a similar all purpose pork pick, with a little less sweetness.
Brisket and beef: a simple 2 to 1 coarse black pepper to kosher salt mix, with a little garlic powder, is hard to beat, and it lets the beef show. If you want a store bought beef rub, Hardcore Carnivore Black is a charcoal and pepper based option that many brisket cooks use.
Chicken and turkey: Kosmos Q Dirty Bird is a popular poultry rub, savory with a little heat, and it works well at 350 to 375 degrees where the skin can crisp. For turkey, a lower sugar rub helps, since sugar can burn at higher heat.
Lawry's Seasoned Salt is a surprise on that list, but it makes sense as a base: salt, sugar, paprika, turmeric, and onion and garlic powder. I use it in my head as a seasoning base, not as a full BBQ rub on its own.
If I had to pick three to keep on hand, it would be Killer Hogs for pork, a pepper and salt mix for beef, and Dirty Bird for poultry.
- Likes 1
Comment
-
Club Member
- Aug 2017
- 10234
- Hate Less, Cook More
-
OUTDOOR COOKERS
BBQ ACCESSORIES
WOOD & PELLET PREFERENCES
SOUS VIDE
INDOOR COOKWARE
First of all there's this "listing" by a guy who starts the web page with "hi I'm Joe". Now I'm sure Joe is a stand up guy and is drawing attention to himself and his self proclamed business, but at the end of the day Joe may like something that I don't like. Also what makes Joe a bloody expert on flavor?
What Joe and all these neigh sayers fail to disclose is that most of these rubs are 30-40% salt in content, THE most important flavor enhancer on the planet. The rest is the same old blend of things like garlic and onion powder, some spice like pepper, a coloring agent like paprika and some sort of agent to prevent caking, especially if sugar is added. So if brand A is mixed slightly different from brand B, you're basically getting the same thing.
Now having said that I have my favorites but also realize I use them because they are convenient. I still tend to make my own basically because I can control the salt content and do dry brine religiously.
So who's if the best? Take your pick.
- Likes 3
Comment
-
My usual go-to's are the rubs on the free side, although I did go down the road of buying, and have a few more than I really need. Honestly though, I find it difficult to use up the commercial rubs. And now, after getting the 4th prize with all those rubs, I'm really going to have to up the cooking game, probably start doing two weeknight cooks, as well as a weekend cook! I foresee a lot of chicken and pork in my future, as well as attempting to use up the beef to make room in the freezer!
-
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.







Comment