I’m planning on a brined turkey smoke this Saturday for our church group.
I was planning on spatchcocking the bird. I bumped into a technique called frog style. Anyone here ever see or do this? How does it compare to spatchcocked when smoking?
I've seen it, but never actually DONE it. I'm just not sure... I mean, it does get the bird flat, which is nice, but it seems like it would take up MORE space - I guess you're flatterning it out and making it LONGER, whereas with spatchcocking you're making it WIDER.
Prolly 6 of one, half a dozen of the other.
I will say this - I watched Al Frugoni doing it, and he is the only one I've seen who made this point - when frogging, you protect the 'oysters' which is a good piece of meat. With spatchcocking, you can lose the oysters, especially if you're not careful. Meh, not a BIG deal, it's about an ounce or two of good meat, a good chef's bonus when you're pulling or butchering after the cook, but not a dealbreaker for me.
Just my $0.02... take it for what it's worth. I'm a spatchcock guy,and I like to do the 'full spatch', removing pelvis/hips, wishbone, keel bone and blade bones. Takes me about an extra 60 seconds on a chikkin and really REALLY makes for easy carving when it's done. Certainly on turkey this is more important, prolly takes me 2 minutes extra time, if that, when prepping.
Bull Frog is another way to spatchcock a bird. I've done both ways with chicken.
The Frog method contains the backbone and its meat but takes up more room on the cooker.
It seems easier to carve the bull frog style than the other style of spatchcocking.
May I suggest getting two small turkeys and do one of each?
For a brined turkey for a group, I would go spatchcock if your cooker space is tight, and frog style if carving at the table matters more to you. They are close cousins, and the difference is mostly in how flat the bird sits and how you carve it. Spatchcock means the backbone comes out completely, the bird lies flat, and the legs splay out. That gives you the most even heat, the fastest cook, and the crispiest skin, because the breast and thighs are at about the same level. It also takes the least room on the grate. Frog style, sometimes called bullfrog, keeps the backbone attached and opens the bird like a book. The bird is still flat, but it takes up more room, and the legs stay more tucked. The advantage bbqLuv mentioned is real: it can be easier to carve, because the backbone and the meat around it stay in place until you cut it. For a Saturday church cook, cook at 275 to 325, and pull the breast at 160 and the thighs at 175, then rest 20 to 30 minutes before carving. Rinse and dry the brined bird well, and let the skin air dry in the fridge for a few hours if you can, so the brine does not keep the skin rubbery. If your bird is over 20 pounds, bbqLuv's idea of two smaller birds, one each way, is a good test, and two 12 pound birds will cook faster and more evenly than one big one.
Some additional opinion. I've done both, as a cooking functionality measure they are roughly the same. What might matter is what you do with the "trimmings". If you use raw, boney components to make stock to get a more gelatinous product then spatchcock would be a better choice. If you prefer a more traditional presentation of the cooked turkey the frog method would be more functional as you simply fold the bird back to its original shape. I don't discern any difference in cooking speed, texture, moisture retention, or skin texture between the two methods.
I guess you may fold the "Frog" back into its original shape. I never considered that.
But wouldn't that take the fun out of serving a Bullfrog Turkey?
Yes, spatchcock takes less space on the grate. Like realdocBBQ I fully spatchcock them, including removing the ribs & femur (upper thigh bone). Makes it super easy to carve.
The BBQ lab guy did a side by side comparison. Came out the same.
Ill probably be smoking 2 small birds so grill space will be important.
Thanks again!
JD
If you’re already spatchcocking the bird, it only takes a few more easy cuts to quarter it. Even easier to handle, easier to fit everything onto the grate, and lets you remove the white meat separately from the dark meat.
I’ve done it with chickens but haven’t tried it yet with a turkey. Al Frugoni has a great video on spatchcocking chickens three different ways. The benefit of the frog cut is that the oyster meat is saved.
Definitely the theme of YouTube and social media - they have to keep inventing and originating new things to keep the attention and the clicks. Yeah, some of the things have been helpful - some of them are just doing more for the sake of doing more. Unhelpful. Is frogging like this? I dunno, I guess to some it's worthwhile in certain situations, it's an alternative method. I'm not overly interested in it, myself.
22” Blue Weber Kettle with SnS insert
Kamado Joe Jr with Kick Ash Basket
Char-Broil Smartchef Tru Infrared Gasser
Anovo Hot Tub Time Machine with Custom Hot Tub
If you’re already spatchcocking the bird, it only takes a few more easy cuts to quarter it. Even easier to handle, easier to fit everything onto the grate, and lets you remove the white meat separately from the dark meat.
Thanks Brian_M,
I’d never considered that. It makes sense. My one concern is this…. Myron Mixon always makes a point of saying, the fewer cuts, the juicier the bird. I suppose if I’m already spatching them, the extra cuts aren’t that significant. Plus, I do see the benefits you mentioned.
I can attest, doing the full spatch is significantly better in the longrun, especially at the carving/serving stage. It does make the bird a bit more floppy, but that's not overly hard to deal with, as I use baking racks or cooling racks alot for birds when spatchcocked. I can't emphasize enough how much better the carving experience is at the end.
Comment