MCS in Reverse: If You Could Only Have One Cooker, Which One?

[Polarbear777]

My pk360. I can do anything on it that fits and it’s the most stable for temps and probably most durable.

[Mr. Bones]

Main, tough call!
Might surprise yall, but:
Reckon my Weber 26/SnS, close race with my Kingsford 24...

[Gunderich_1]

I think we are brothers from another Mother. I agree 100%. The Weber 26 is an amazing tool. And I had the Kingsford. I donated it to my son but unfortunately a really bad wind took it off their raised deck and it didn't survive. It was a really good unit considering it was a cheap model.

[Troutman]

Yup !

[Steve B]

Uh....... No. Need my cookers.


But if I really had to. My LoneStar Grillz.

[Spinaker]

I would have to say the BGE. It is the most versatile and the rig I use the most. Although I don't think I could go on without the KBQ.

[EdF]

I can definitely relate, OmegaDog12 !

[Spinaker]

👊🏻 OmegaDog12

[Cheef]

Yep the BGE for sure. Close second would be the PK360.
My absolute first to go and be gone would be my Memphis Pro. An expensive step into pellet poopers, and a lesson learned.

[PaulstheRibList]

One pit...man, that's tough. I guess I would go Jambo stickburner smoker!

Then I'd grill burgers/steaks/etc. on a grate over the firepit!

[Dusty]

Performer and the SNS with griddle/drip pan. There is nothing that I cannot do on that combination and it is the lazy mans grill, I don’t even have to set down my bourbon to fill the chimney, turn on the gas and hit the igniter. Finish my bourbon, dump the coals and off to the races.

[bten]

My Delta Heat Gas Grill. I can do almost anything on it with a smoker tube. If I could only have one, that would be it.

[Sweaty Paul]

Tough question. Love all my cookers, however, I’d go with my Yoder YS-640. Get the smoke and direct grilling. Can even put a griddle over top of opened diffuser plate.

That said, I do love all of my cookers.

[MBMorgan]

Blasphemy, I know ... but I’d have to say my Weber EP-330 with the Baking Steel griddle ... but I’d try real hard to sneak in a Grilla Grilla Pellet pooper into an unnoticed corner of the deck.

[Attjack]

I would definitely keep my Primo XL. But I'm glad I don't have to make that choice. I use both my Weber 26 and JJ, the Weber Spirit, and the Primo all the time.

At the cabin the Weber 22 would be the one.

[smokenoob]

It would be my Official Red Ryder Carbine-Action Two-Hundred-Shot Range Model Air Rifle! oops, wrong thread

[Troutman]

Nope because you'd shoot your eye out

[smokenoob]

Is that you dad?

[jfmorris]

See he can't even tell who it is! He already shot his eye out!

[rwalters]

The K750HS Hybrid Freestanding Grill with Sideburner. Period.
by Kalamazoo Grills.

I’ve asked my wife and daughters for this very grill for the past 10+ fathers days. I am still waiting...

[lostclusters]

It must be time to take matters in to your own hands!

[CandySueQ]

I'm actually in cooker reduction mode! Still haven't counted in a while...so, here's my current list

Rolling Cookers
Woodmaster Mini Hog
Jambo J-3 with pellet fire
Yoder Cimarron Pellet

Large BGE
Grilla
MAK 2 star
Green Mountain Daniel Boone with pizza oven attachment
Duchess (pre PK)
large Gateway Drum
small Gateway Drum
Smokey Joe
Jumbo Joe
Weber Smoky Mountain 14.5
Weber Smoky Mountain 22.5
Hasty Bake (old "portable" model I don't think they make anymore)
Traeger 22 mag (this should just be tossed -- missing hardware and it wasn't much account when solid)
Cobb portable grill
Hot Box portable grill
FEC100

3 Weber Kettles on the back porch at work
Two Trees double metal wall mini-kamado

This is a hard exercise for me obviously! For household use, the BGE or WSM would be the most flexible, but I use the Grilla ALL THE TIME!!!

Of my rolling stock, the Yoder is my favorite.

[FireMan]

Cooker reduction? Yeah sure!

[klflowers]

In an earlier post, I mentioned that I had an obsession with cookers. Man was I wrong...

[rwalters]

Super tough call...but with a super busy family, I’d have to go with my MAK pellet grill.

[PWB0108]

Easy, my Performer with the SNS. Not much I can't do on it.