Weber gas newbie G2 E335 , 30 yr Weber charcoal expert, not happy...

[mikez]

30 year + Weber charcoal guy. Have burned/used up 3 old school W kettles, and 4 Performers, some junk Brinkman electric/charcoal smokers, still liking my Smokey Joe.

My honey bought me for 60 bday , Weber GII E-355 with sear burner, nice machine but...
Nothing tastes right ! or good!. I have done dogs/brats/burgers/steaks p-chops dont taste right/good.

Yes I did new grill burn off, vaporizers/diffusers were orange hot for for 2.5 hours, then 2.5 hrs at half power.
I did not think food would taste better on gas, but also did not think it would suck.

Or am I just a charcoal snob ?

[RonB]

My wife used to know someone who sold high(er) end gas grills to dealers. He sold one of his demo gassers to us at the end of the summer years ago. I think I used it twice before selling it. I just love the flavor charcoal gives food...

So, from my point of view, the answer to your question is no.

[zero_credit]

I'd also agree the answer to your question is no. Perhaps time to trade in for a Hasty Bake or the Good One smoker?

[JGo37]

You're a charcoal snob. Just like me. Man, wood, fire.

(don't get technical on me folks - you get my drift... LoL)

Gas is for vehicles and landscaping equipment, not meat.

(I do own a Blackstone, but that's TOTALLY different)

[jfmorris]

Wow - that is crazy burning off for that long. I think 30 minutes would have been plenty! I washed the grates, then burned off for 30 I think, when I got my Genesis II last year. Maybe you induced an off flavor by getting the flavorizer bars red hot? I've never seen mine turn red. Do you smell any funky odor to the grill itself, when not cooking?

I have had both Weber charcoal and gas grills for years (a Genesis 2 burner since 2002), and currently have a Weber Genesis II E-410 4 burner grill, and a Weber Performer Deluxe. I also have a large offset that doubles as a charcoal grill that I've been using since the 80's.

I cook certain things only on charcoal, but any time I have a big cook and its just burgers, chicken or even some reverse seared steaks and I don't have a spare half hour to get the Performer going, I use the Genesis. The food from the Genesis doesn't suck, but it doesn't have the same wood/charcoal smoke flavor as the kettle. It has smoke generated from drippings sizzling when they burn up on the hot flavorizer bars.

The best thing I ever did for my gas grill was to install a full replacement set of Grillgrates. However, my son has a 3 burner Spirit II, and grills all sorts of stuff, with the stock cast iron grates. The Grillgrates mostly increase searing heat, and reduce flareups. And make for good Smashburgers on the flat side! I almost used the Weber as a griddle more than a grill, before getting a dedicated griddle.

I think you are just missing the smoke. And maybe you are drying stuff out? I think a propane grill can tend to do that if you run the heat too high.

[FireMan]

Ever think of usin wood chips to give some smoke. Might change things fer ya.
BTW, welcome, eat good and have fun!

[ScottyC13]

I use both a Weber gasser and Performer. Food tastes great on both, but they are different.

[cgrover60]

I'm trying to wrap my head around the number of cooks it would take to burn through 3 kettles and 4 perfomers. Charcoal is it for sure. I use a gasser strictly for quick convenience as a last resort.

[Locknut]

I have to agree with cgrover 60. 3 kettles and 4 performers. I still have my Weber kettle after 31 years and it gets used at least weekly. I did replace the grates with a stainless hinged version about 15 years ago. The wood handles are way better than the plastic ones. I have a weber ss Spirit gas, and it is about 20. It gets used for quick cooking. I also have a Weber Smoky Mountain Bullet smoker. They are all great when used for their strong points. I believe that time and use will take care of your gas grill problem. I'm not accusing, but a decent grill cover can prolong the life of your grills...just sayin.

[ofelles]

Wlcome from the California Delta. That's some serious grilln' to go through that many grills.

[HouseHomey]

Perhaps Use less lighter fluid. ha!!

I don’t know, that’s a strange one indeed.

For sure different flavors from coal though.

[bbqLuv]

I went from Charcoal to gas and stayed with gas for years. Then went to pellet grill, and never looked back at either.

[Parkin]

I got a Weber Spirit NG earlier this year and was also very underwhelmed with it. Added Grill Grates and powered through cooking on it and can report that the initial "meh" taste I was getting from it, has gotten a lot better...Pellets or chips burning on the GG's helps a bunch. It's never going to replace charcoal, but the more I use it, the better stuff is tasting.

[Steve R.]

A little seasoning from using it for awhile might help. Maybe cook a package of cheap bacon in there before using it for anything else again. Honestly, I think the "charcoal flavor" is really from the smoke created by the grease and whatnot dripping directly onto the hot coals. Completely lit charcoal on its own is a fairly neutral heat source, imho.

[Mr. Bones]

Howdy from Kansas Territory, Welcome to Th Pit!
Lookin forward to learnin along with, an from ya, Mate!

No answer to yer questions; ain't never once had me no gasser. Sry.