I just reviewed the Southern Living Top 50 BBQ joints. I counted that I have been to seventeen of them covering five states. I didn’t grow up with BBQ so that bias is not in my impression. There may be a bias in that I used to sample Southern Living’s previous lists before I moved to Texas and started following Texas Monthly’s top 50. My experience with Southern Living’s previous lists was that it was mostly hit and miss and one place was in my personal worst BBQ list. Anyway, I know that your favorite style of BBQ can influence what you think of a particular BBQ joint. Of the seventeen I have eaten at I would say they are all good. What surprised me was that without comparing across regional BBQ styles was the order of the Texas BBQ joints from which is the region that I have the most samples. The Texas joint that almost all of the Texas Meat Up participants considered the best in Texas was rated below other joints we had sampled. I guess the rating will always be in the mouth of the taster, but I doubt if you will go wrong with any of the joints on that list.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Southern Living’s Top 50
Collapse
X
-
Club Member
- Aug 2020
- 9358
- Houston, Tx.
-
SnS Master Kettle
SnS Insert For the Kettle
SNS Rotisserie Kit
Vortex
Pit Boss Ultimate 2 Burner Griddle
ThermoWorks Remote Dual Probe Thermometer
ThermoPro TP-19 Instant Read Meat Thermometer
Choice brand portable gas burner
Wakoli Damascus Steel 6 piece Knife Set
-
Club Member
- May 2017
- 3409
- La Crescenta, CA
-
Jambo Backyard Smoker
KBQ
Weber Smokey Mountain (22" & 18.5")
PK360
PK Original Grill
Pit Barrel Cooker
Weber "Brownie" Circa 1978 22"
Weber 70th Anniversary model 22"
Weber Genesis
Weber Gas Grill, Silver A
Santa Maria Attachment for PK360
Vortex
Favorite Beer: Peroni
Favorite Sports Teams: Rams, Dodgers, Kings, UCLA Bruins
Leroy & Lewis at #5. The author must have had a good day there. Near the bottom of my Texas Meat-up list. Barbs at #28.....no way. Listing Smitty's is a head scratcher.
Robert Moss must be from California.
- Likes 5
Comment
-
Agree. Leroy and Lewis was one of the most disappointing places I’ve visited in Texas. It wasn’t “bad” but would rank them in the bottom half of all the places I’ve gone. Smitty’s glory days were 20 years ago, they shouldn’t be on anyone’s list. Hurtado’s we just visited on Saturday and they certainly deserved their spot they received on the list IMO.
- 2 likes
-
Unfortunately gotta agree with you guys. Been there twice now, love that they "re-imagine" barbecue but nothing I had there was what I consider top tier, much less in the TM Top 10. Oh well, maybe a little politicking and under-the-table going on, if you catch my drift.
- 1 like
-
Club Member
- Aug 2018
- 2921
- Lone Star State
-
Weber MT Kettle, SnS, DnG, Easy Spin Stainless Steel Grate, Elevated SnS SS Cooking Grate, Vortex, Cajun Bandit Rotisserie, Oklahoma Joe Bronco, OKJ Bronco Triple Grate, Mini Weber Kettle ashtray Maverick XR-50, TimeStick Trio
I spent most of my working life living in the SE but traveling nationally and ate mostly pork and chicken BBQ over Hickory. Over many, many years, I have been to 13 places mentioned on the list. I have been to Fresh Air in Jackson Ga the most often because my employer had a manufacturing plant in Jackson. It was pork and Brunswick stew. At the time, Fresh Air was a very old school simple BBQ joint and the wooden interior smelled of years of smoking pork. For me the BBQ was mainly pork and chicken. I never really had any beef BBQ nor did I want any until moving to Texas. I thought brisket was only for deli sandwiches. Now, I like it all and it all can be very different. For my first time, I had smoked lamb ribs at Goldee's BBQ on Friday and quail at Hurtado's BBQ on Saturday. I like trying BBQ other than the traditional Texas Trinity of brisket, ribs and sausage. BTW,I have rack of lamb and leg of lamb a lot but never had lamb ribs. I had pulled lamb at Interstellar during a past MeatUp. I want to try the mutton at Old Hickory BBQ in Kentucky.
I think it's hard to compare different regional BBQ when the meats, wood selection, rubs, smoking methods, sides, chopped/pulled/sliced etc are different. How do you compare pulled Boston butt pork with tomato base sauce sandwich to a whole hog chopped then mixed pork with a vinegar based sauce sandwich?
These lists are fun to read and debate who's in, who's out and their ranking. Also gives you a list to BBQ to try in a given area.Last edited by Purc; October 26, 2026, 06:51 PM.
- Likes 4
Comment
-
Club Member
- Feb 2019
- 2461
- Salado, Tx
-
Summerset TRL44 gas grill and side sear
Weber 70th Anniversary kettle, Hot Rod Yellow
Camp Chef Somerset IV 4 burner propane stove
OT QOMOTOP 23-inch Gas Griddle
Pit Boss Ultimate 4 burner griddle
Oklahoma Joe's HD orange Bronco
Oklahoma Joe's Bronco Pro
Oklahoma Joe's Judge
Oklahoma Joe's Rambler
Golden's Cast Iron Grill
Ooni Koda 16
Halo Versa 16
Everdure Kiln R pizza oven
Everdure rotisserie grill
Titan Santa Maria grill
Coyote Pellet grill
Hasty Bake Roughneck smoker
LSG 48" Texas Edition offset
Spider Grills Huntsman
Big Horn infrared

As the author suggests it's about personal taste. A site can be judge some level of good or bad based on an individual serving. This was brought home to me this past weekend at Goldee's. While standing in line the cutter passed us a few sample cuts (single bite size) from a hunk of brisket in front of him. It was one of the best bites of brisket I have ever had. It was slightly firm (a good thing), nicely smokey, and tasty bark. If I were judging by that piece alone they'd have been at the top of my list. The slices we got on our tray, on the other hand, were not quite as good from a texture standpoint, while having similar flavoring. Overall it was good brisket, just a tiny bit toward the fall-a-party side, and room temperature to boot. Some of you may prefer that, and that's the point. When we went to Dayne's some time back I felt we got a mediocre brisket. Flavor was a bit light, and it was crumbly (not dry though) under the fork. You could barely pick it up without it falling apart. Since we were practically at the front of the line my guess was we got a brisket that had been held over from the previous day (which could mean it was out of the smoker for two or maybe more days living in a holding box).
- Likes 6
Comment
-
Club Member
- Oct 2016
- 1957
- White Stone Va
-
Smokers / Grills
Weber 22" w/ SnS, GrillGrates & Vortex
Pit Barrel Cooker
22" Blackstone
Meadow Creek PR42G
GMG Trek w/ Pizza insert
OKJ Bronco
Weber Searwood 600 XL
Thermometers
Lavatools Javelin
Thermoworks Thermopen mk4 qty 2
Thermoworks SmokeX4
Thermoworks Thermopop qty 2
Thermoworks RFX Gateway w/ 4 probes
Thermoworks Dot
Maverick XR-50 qty 2
Instagram and Facebook @bkydbbq
I have been to eleven of the ones on this list and I think they all deserve to be there.
This list came out in 2025, even though it says updated in January 2026.
Keep in mind that there are hundreds (just in Texas) if not thousands of BBQ joints in the South so the decision makers are not able to try all of them. They have to work with what they can reasonably sample.
I know two of the places on this list are closed; Redemption BBQ in Henrico, Va and Rodney Scott's BBQ.
At least this list is better than the list Southern Living does based on reader's popularity vote, there is no way Pierce's is the Best BBQ in Virginia and I will die on that hill, they aren't even the best BBQ in Williamsburg, Va.
- Likes 2
Comment
-
jayjordan , and oh yeah, the bbq, we're a mix of KC and Texas. So we kinda get overlooked.
Dan Vaughn made a list of best Texas bbq outside state of Texas. I joint here in OKC made #9 on his list and a place in far SE made hon mention.
But pork with a sweet tangy sauce dominates. I grew up on ribs. Comp cooks opening up joints is most of our bbq , especially the Tulsa region.
- 1 like
-
Lynn Dollar I use to have a customer in Anadarko, OK and we ate at Jake's BBQ in Chickasha. I don't remember the ribs, but I do remember the HUGE amount of fries in one order.
-
Purc Jakes is still there, but its lost its luster. Not as highly thought of, most in Chickasha say its really gone downhill. I've not been there, just heard about it.
-
Club Member
- Jul 2020
- 327
- Omaha, Nebraska
-
Pit Barrel Cooker
Grilla Grills Kong
RecTec BT380 Bullseye
Fireboard 2 Drive w/Blower
Thermoworks Mk4
Founder BBQ AF
https://www.facebook.com/groups/bbqaf/
Instagram: @bbq_af1
I've only been to a few of these. Micklethwait's and Hurtado were my faves. I have some work to do...
- Likes 1
Comment
-
Club Member
- Sep 2018
- 1669
- Fishers, IN, USA
-
Cookers I use:
Lang 48 inch Deluxe Patio Model (burns hickory splits)
PK 360 (burns premium lump charcoal with wood chunks)
28 inch Blackstone Griddle (propane)
Rubs I love:
Yardbird by Plow Boys
Killer Hogs by Malcom Reed
AP Rub by Malcom Reed
Meat Church (any)
Three Little Pigs Memphis Style for ribs
Would love to try Meathead's commercial rub
Sauces I love:
Gates'
Joe's
Pa & Ma's
Killer Hogs Vinegar Sauce
Disposable Equipment I use:
Disposable cutting boards
Tumbleweed chimney starters
Aluminum foil
Aluminum pans (half and full)
Latex gloves
Diamond Kosher Salt
Vice-President of BBQ Security, Roy
He's a pure-bred North American Brown Dog
He loves rawhide chewies
My wife calls me "Teddy" and I call her "Princess" and that's where "mrteddyprincess" comes from.
Sorry, Old Hickory in Owensboro does NOT belong above Cozy Corner in Memphis. Nope. Not in this world. Don't get me wrong. I love Old Hickory, but I love Cozy Corner even more. In my world, Cozy Corner is number one. Old Hickory? Yep. If you love Mutton. Owensboro is king of mutton and worth visiting when you get the chance.
IMHO.
B
- Likes 1
Comment
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.







Comment