Instagram AmazingRibs Facebook AmazingRibs X - Meathead Pinterest AmazingRibs Youtube AmazingRibs
BBQ Stars

Welcome!


This is a membership forum. Guests can view 5 pages for free. To participate, please join.

[ Pitmaster Club Information | Join Now | 30 Day Trial | Login | Contact Us ]

Only 4 free page views remaining.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

New to brewing - Questions for the elite Brewmasters here

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    New to brewing - Questions for the elite Brewmasters here

    Hey everyone,

    My boss just gave me his complete brewing setup. Two primary plastic buckets, three secondary glass 5 gallon bottles, a "filler" bucket with a spout for easy bottling, a couple stainless steel pots for boiling, and a bunch of diffusers, tubing, syphons, airlocks, extra caps, fittings, etc... He hadn't used it for a long time, was stored in his basement and he decided he wasn't going to brew anymore.

    So I've never done this before. I get the sanitation part, so I was looking at getting some Star San, but before I load up on sanitizers, brewers' yeast, hops, barely, etc... I would like your opinions on what you've found from experience is the best way to start.

    I see Amazon has ready made beer ingredients kits, and lots of supplies/equipment, but it looks like the local guys I have here are pretty dang competitive on pricing.

    1. Know of any good tutorials or books I should think about?
    2. Should I look local, rather than buy things online? There's a few brewing suppliers not far from me that have good ratings.
    3. Should I think about attending a class? (I see suppliers offering them).
    4. If someone gave you a complete setup, especially one that has been stored for awhile, what equipment would you just simply go buy new instead of reusing (if any)?
    5. Recipes, and/or links to recipes.
    6. Suggestions on what sanitizers to use?

    What am I thinking about brewing? Well, darker German beers, like Dunkle are some of my favorites. Blonde ale or Pale ale would probably be the next thing I try. And I think starting with a kit of ingredients might be the way to go?

    Where do I plan on brewing this? Basement. I have a finished and unfinished part with the mechanicals/washer/dryer. If those two places were your choice, would you make room in the unfinished or finished portion? It's pretty dry down there, no mold or unpleasant smells, and stays very temperate all year round. Pretty sure the garage or shed are no-go's due to temperature swings and sanitary conditions.

    Opinions welcome, on both kits you've seen, used, and liked, or why you don't use a kit and roll your own.

    Thanks in advance. Oh, and I can't believe Property Management is "ok" with this. I'm pretty sure I might get some flack once she sees all the stuff.

    #2
    jfmorris

    Comment


    • Alan Brice
      Alan Brice commented
      Editing a comment
      +1

    #3
    1 - "How to Brew" by John Palmer. A lot has changed since it was published but the fundamentals are there.
    2 - Buy local! When something goes wrong, or you can't wait days/weeks for a part or ingredient, you're going to want to have a place to buy it today.
    3 - Up to you. I never did but people seem to like the camaraderie.
    4 - I'd get new tubing and some other smaller plastic things. Metal and glass clean up nicely.
    5 - Recipes are everywhere. Google your favorite beers with "copycat" but most people start with an amber or a pale ale.
    6 - Any of the no-rinse sanitizers are fine. Iodine-based will stain but work fine when diluted. Don't be stingy with your cleaning agents.

    Many German beers like Dunkels are lagers which in general are a bit more difficult because of temperature requirements but can still be done.
    As far as the basement goes, you'll be boiling several gallons of liquid for a couple hours so you'll need ventilation and ideally you have a sink/drain nearby.
    Kits are fine as well, but you have less control over the freshness of the ingredients in them.

    Comment


    • dpearce
      dpearce commented
      Editing a comment
      Thanks for the info jtw I do have a sink down here, but I will probably boil the water in the garage with my turkey fryer burner. My boss did this, and said he then used a second container as an ice bath to cool it down enough to bring it in the house. Does that sound right? Also, thinking I will use jugs of purified water from the store rather than our sink water?

    • jtw
      jtw commented
      Editing a comment
      keep in mind that it takes a long time to cool down 5 gallons of boiling water, and it's heavy and difficult to carry, especially down a flight of stairs. you can use a wort chiller to speed it up but still count on 30 minutes. I use tap water but we have really good water here in Detroit, so if you're on a well or don't have decent drinkable tap water then you may want purified water.

    • dpearce
      dpearce commented
      Editing a comment
      jtw our local tap water is pretty chlorinated, our city gets it from Columbus, and no one around here drinks it unless they absolutely have to. We've had filters on our showers for a long time as well. It's fine for washing dishes, but . We've been doing bottled water or purifying jugs for decades. And yes, I was thinking through the logistics of carrying the water down the stairs. If I can do it all in the garage and save the trip, that would be a huge plus.

    #4
    jfmorris in a heartbeat.

    Comment


      #5
      Yes, I defer to jfmorris for this. I make wine and I've dabbled in beer back in the day. I suggest getting to know your local beer supply shop and talk to them. Start off with beer kits and work your way up to all grain if that's what you'd like long term. The kits are about even on the cost. You can buy two cases of beer for about the same price as the kit supplies you buy, but that's a good way to get into brewing and learn the process. Whole grain brewing can come later. And if you grow tired of beer, switch over to wine. It's a lot easier :-)

      Brian

      Comment


      • dpearce
        dpearce commented
        Editing a comment
        Thanks Brian! Wine "could" be in the future! That's something I didn't think about. The missus is not much into wines, but it would be nice to have some on hand for company, and to give myself a break from the everyday stuff.

      #6
      I haven't brewed a batch in over 30 years. Dang, I can't believe it's been that long now that I think about it. However the process is still pretty much the same, so here is where I would start.

      I would start with extracts before jumping into whole grains. Your local supplier should be able to help you out with what you need. You want to get to know them and use them as a resource. Your first stop should be at a local supplier, to get a feel for them. Let them know that you are just getting started and are looking for something basic to run as a first batch.

      This is the book I started with.

      A class is an excellent idea just to get familiar with the process and the parts and pieces involved.

      If everything is in good shape, use what you have. I would be tempted to get new air locks simply because a failed air lock makes a mess that is no fun to clean up. Makes for a great story after the fact, but still...

      As long as your equipment is clean and sanitized, you can easily brew in the garage or shed. You don't need an sterile operating room to brew in.

      Home brew clubs can be a lot of fun, or a real drag. It all depends on the people in the club.

      Start thinking now about getting a dedicated fridge for fermenting. Even ales work better in a temperate controlled environment. It's not required to start with, but will be soon if you get bit by the brewing bug.

      Finally, it's just beer. Don't stress out about it.

      Comment


      • dpearce
        dpearce commented
        Editing a comment
        Thank you! I plan on stopping tomorrow, after a quick doctor's appointment! They're literally just a few blocks away from where I'm going and not all that far from the house. Read up on the reviews, and people seem to really like this place. I've driven that stretch of road more times than I can remember, and never even knew the place was there! Yes, the airlocks are suspect, we even talked about that when we were loading up my car, so that, along with any rubber gaskets.

      • dpearce
        dpearce commented
        Editing a comment
        WI Bubba so you've peaked my interest with your comment about brewing in the garage or the shed. It would be easier if I didn't have to do this in the basement, plus probably make my wife much happier. Out of sight, out of mind, ya know. Winters and summers here, we get pretty decent temperature swings, so I just assumed it wouldn't be a good idea. I'd love to find out more about my options of where I can do this, and what I might have to anticipate for.

      #7
      John Palmer’s How To Brew is a great book to start with. John knows his stuff, and even though it’s been around a long time the basics are unchanged. I read it cover to cover twice before my first brew and it made a difference.

      The Brewing Network is also a great resource. They have 20 years of podcasts available with regulars and guests who are pillars in the Homebrewing and professional brewing industry.

      I’m a huge fan of buying local. Not only are you supporting a local business, but you have a real human to work with. Most homebrew shop owners and employees are experienced brewers who can help point you in the right direction. They’ll also have brew days or demonstrations. Whether it’s a shop demo or a group brew day you’ll get to see it done in person and be able to ask all the questions. You can also take in your beer for evaluation - invaluable feedback!

      As far as equipment, I’d replace everything that’s not metal or glass, especially if it’s cold side (post-boil) equipment. Those plastic primary buckets…BYE! Also, you can use the glass carboys for primary, and I wouldn’t worry about secondary right away. The less you move the beer the less opportunity for contamination.

      Recipes abound online, and the Homebrewing community has advanced tremendously, so you have a lot of options. Your local homebrew shop probably has kits, which is a great place to start.

      My brewing adventure started almost 20 years ago with extract and steeping grains. About a year later I switched to all-grain. One of the “rights of passage” most homebrewers navigate that I completely skipped is bottling…I kegged from day one. Faster, easier, and as I said earlier…the less you move finished beer the less chance for contamination!

      Comment


      • dpearce
        dpearce commented
        Editing a comment
        Thanks for the advice! Looked up a video on YouTube, and the guy was detailing out his all-grain process with the barley. I had no idea how much time that takes! Wow. I imagine it's quite a step up, otherwise no one would do it!

      #8
      Hey guys - I see I’ve been paged. Unfortunately I see nothing about a brewing vessel (pot), a mash tun for mashing grain, or other critical components. The buckets and carboys are just for fermenting. It seems like he gave you the cold side stuff - post brew chilled wort - but not the hot side equipment for making wort. A turkey fryer is what I started with.

      I’ve got to crash and get some sleep, but will respond with more info from my computer in the morning.

      I will advise not buying kits on Amazon. Places I would look include MoreBeer.com and NorthernBrewer.com for ingredient kits. I personally buy grain locally and online, and make my own recipes.

      I can’t type anymore on this iPad. I’ll be back in the morning to offer advice as needed.

      Comment


      • ComfortablyNumb
        ComfortablyNumb commented
        Editing a comment
        "a couple stainless steel pots for boiling"

        You need some sleep.

        He only needs a mash tun if using grain. Most beginners start with extracts. The fellow who gifted him the equipment probably never advanced,

      • dpearce
        dpearce commented
        Editing a comment
        ComfortablyNumb you are correct, setup was used a few times, then life, wife, kids, stole the time. Plus he probably didn't need all the beer as much either! It's just me and missus for the most part, and this will give me something to do in the evenings after work. Plus, I do like better beer than I show in my posts, but rarely ever buy it for myself.
        Last edited by dpearce; October 28, 2026, 09:04 AM.

      • dpearce
        dpearce commented
        Editing a comment
        jfmorris you're correct, there's no mash tun. He'd brewed from kits, so nothing to handle the grain side of the house. He did give me several stainless pots for boiling, and I have a propane burner from the turkey fryer I plan on using. Boil outside or in the garage, then ice bath (or maybe pick up a cooling coil or make one), then haul it down to the basement for the next phases. I'll definitely need to read up and talk to folks before attempting anything though!
        Last edited by dpearce; October 28, 2026, 09:06 AM.

      #9
      I'm not an all grain brewer - too much equipment and space needed plus it takes more time but it is considered the best method by many brewers. jfmorris and other members can guide you through this method.

      I use extract with specialty grains, boil on my gas stove or Cajun burner outside, ferment and secondary are both in plastic buckets which can be stacked for storage. I usually buy kits but I have several recipes that I use as well. If I were you I would start with kits to learn the process, they will have instructions with them and have everything needed for a batch of beer: muslin bag, extract, specialty grains, hops, yeast. Basically you take the specialty grains, usually it is about 1-4 lbs, and put them into a muslin bag. Heat the water to about 160o and put the grain bag in. Stir the water several times while steeping to circulate water through the bag - like making tea. Remove after about 20-30 minutes, bring to a boil, add the extract, bring back to a boil and add the bittering hops, boil for an hour - watch and adjust the burner so that it doesn't foam up and overflow. Add flavor/ aroma hops during the last 5-10 minutes of the boil. Turn off the burner and cool the liquid (called "wort") as quickly as possible - set pot in ice water or use a cooling system - I made a copper coil that I place in the pot and run water through to cool the wort. Pour into the fermentation bucket, top off with boiled cooled water to the correct level (usually 5 gallons) and add the yeast and ferment.

      I started kegging years ago to save the time and effort of bottling - if you have helpers the bottling is not too bad but it takes awhile if you are flying solo. Kegs require a dispensing system - I found a free 1982 Frigidaire fridge and converted it into a 5 tap keggerator. Kegs take up space but I keep extra kegs in the shed outside. The glass carboys/bottles take up may too much space and are awkward to handle and clean - I sold the ones that were given too me.

      Comment


      • ComfortablyNumb
        ComfortablyNumb commented
        Editing a comment
        All my gear is packed away, but my conical fermenter has a dump valve at the bottom and another valve a few inches above that. All the yeast settles in the bottom of the cone below the valve. I then rack off the finished wort by opening the valve and letting gravity empty the fermenter. Then I dump the yeast into a sanitized flask. Clean out the fermenter, put in fresh wort, and then repitch the yeast from the flask, which takes off immediately. No siphoning, no dumping yeast. Easy peasey.

      • dpearce
        dpearce commented
        Editing a comment
        ComfortablyNumb that was more "beer brewing speak" than I was able to process. Even re-reading it, I am still left with questions, but I do think the glass carboys are somewhat of a challenge. You wouldn't happen to have a nicely diagramed layout of your setup, would you? By the way, one of my favorite guitar solos is Pink Floyd's Comfortably Numb. Saw them in '94 at OSU stadium.

      • ComfortablyNumb
        ComfortablyNumb commented
        Editing a comment
        dpearce I will answer in a post so as it my be too verbose for a comment.

      #10
      dpearce Ok, I am back and on my second mug of coffee today! I totally missed the "pots for boiling" thing,

      It sounds like what you have is an extract brewing setup. The difference is - with extract, you are reconstituting "wort" (think of it as barley-sugar water) from a dried malt extract (DME) or liquid malt extract (LME). You are skipping the mashing portion of the process, which requires a mash tun and crushed grain. I started this way, and brewed exactly twice as an extract brewer before jumping into all grain brewing, by building a mash tun using an old Igloo cooler, and some CPVC pipe and plumbing parts from Lowe's.

      Another difference between extract and all-grain brewing, is that most extract brewers boil a smaller volume (say 3-4 gallons), to fit in a smaller 5 gallon pot, and top it off with water to reach the batch volume (usually 5 to 5.5 gallons in the fermenter). With all grain, since I am producing the wort, not reconstituting it, I boil 7 gallons down to about 5.5 over 60 minutes, so it requires a larger pot - larger than you think to avoid boil overs in fact.

      I brew in my 2 car garage. As long as you keep things SANITARY during the process, and do not touch the cooled wort with anything that has not been sanitized using Starsan (that is what I recommend and use), then you are fine. Same applies when bottling or kegging the finished beer after fermentation. What you likely do NOT want to do is slep 5-6 gallons of hot liquid between the garage and basement, so I would setup where you are doing the brewing, even if you move the sealed fermentation vessel down to the basement (CAREFULY!) after it is filled and sealed.

      "How to Brew" by John Palmer has been mentioned, and is dated (90's), but still useful to skim through. There is a free older edition of it online, but he apparently is not maintaining the site well, as it has an expired certificate - if you push through the warning, you can read the content there.

      My recommendation for your initial brews would be to go to Northen Brewer, as they have the largest selection of quality extract brewing kits. Also, for now, select a dry yeast option, as that will save you some work. Liquid yeast can produce better results, but adds additional requirements for a sanitized starter vessel, stir plate, and more work days ahead of the brew. Skip that for now.

      Your first focus on this should be:
      1. Buy a quality kit or two somewhere like Northern Brewer, in a style you like. It will have step by step instructions, and they turn over inventory enough that the ingredients should be fresh.
      2. Get down the PROCESS.
      3. Make sure you understand SANITIZATION. This is the biggest failure when you start brewing. Beer that gets contaminated, after the boil, or after fermentation, can go bad in a truly horrible way! Do not be shy with mixing up a 5 gallon bucket full of star san solution each brew day or bottling day. Sanitize the heck out of everything!
      4. Do you best to ferment under a controlled temperature. Temperature swings and temps that are too high or too low for the yeast are a huge cause of beer flaws.
      5. Learn to be PATIENT. Resist the urge to ask "is it done" every day of the ferment. Give the beer 2 full weeks in primary before considering bottling or kegging.
      6. SKIP THE SECONDARY. Unless this is a super high ABV beer that requires extended aging. No one in my brew club has been doing secondaries in decades. I consider my beer keg to be the secondary, and if its a 10-12% beer, I just let it age longer in the keg before drinking.
      7. ENJOY the beer YOU MADE!
      Only if you are successful in a few rounds of extract beer would I think about advancing to all-grain. I find all-grain to produce superior results, but have had some truly excellent extract beers other brewers have made over the years. A lot has to do with the process, yeast health, temperature control, and freshness of ingredients.

      On water:

      I use filtered water here, as chlorine or chloramines in brewing water can cause flaws in brewed beer, that you can taste. A carbon block filter eliminates it, or setting the brewing water out overnight in buckets can let it dissipate as well. Other ways can be used to remove chlorine, but I highly recommend you do this. An RV type filter that attaches to a hose is one option that is $15-20. I am using the water filter under my kitchen sink, and carrying 2 gallon buckets of water out to the garage, one at a time...

      On chilling:

      For extract brewing with a small volume pot (say 3 to 4 gallons), yes, you can put it in the sink with ice, and I did that a couple times. The best method is an immersion chiller, that you run hose water or chilled water through, which is inserted into the pot during the boil, and then rapidly reduces the temperature. Save that type of work until you know if you LIKE brewing, and just sacrifice some ice for now.

      On covering the pot:

      DO NOT convert the pot during a boil! Doing so causes sulfur compounds and other elements in the wort that need to off-gas to instead drip back into the pot, causing flaws such as DMS. Only cover the pot with a sanitized lid once you start cooling the wort after the boil.

      On bottling:

      I have bottled a few times. It sucks to sanitized 52 bottles, then fill and cap them. But it is doable. If you do it once or twice and like the beer, then I recommend looking into beer kegs. ONE thing to sanitize and fill rather than 52! But it requires an investment (if your wife will let you call it that, haha!).

      Ask any more specific questions and I'll try to answer. Sorry to ramble so long. Brewing and BBQ are two of my long time hobbies...

      Jim

      Comment


      • 58limited
        58limited commented
        Editing a comment
        The Wyeast smash packs do not require a stir plate or starter vessel for a 5 gallon batch. You just have to plan ahead and smash the pack before brewing or you might have raw wort waiting for a day while the yeast activates. Most beer kits have the option to get this instead of dry yeast. https://homebrewing.org/collections/...-brewing-yeast

      • jfmorris
        jfmorris commented
        Editing a comment
        58limited very true, but only if two conditions are met:

        1. The pack is pretty fresh (within a couple months of its manufacturing date, and well before the best use-by date).
        2. The beer to be fermented is a 5 gallon batch around 1.050 gravity or less.

        And I'll add:

        3. The yeast has been stored in the fridge at all times, and did not suffer heat during warm weather shipping.

        In most cases, I am brewing at gravities or batch sizes, or with yeast old enough to need a starter...

      #11
      dpearce I got into brewing in much the same way as what you describe.

      My co-worker in Atlanta, a long time friend, was going through a divorce, and while I was over there on business from Huntsville back around 2005, he offered to give me all the brewing stuff in his basement. So I loaded it up in the back seat of the truck, and brought it back to Huntsville with me. He had a full extract setup, with buckets, carboys, siphon, 5 gallon pot, and 3 kegs and a CO2 regulator and tank.

      It then SAT IN MY GARAGE for a number of years, with the wife threatening to get rid of it if I didn't do something with it. After about 5 years, around 2010 I finally told her I was going to use it, and I talked to a friend I knew had been brewing since the 90's, went to a home brew club meeting with him, and dove in with an extract kit, and took the results to the club meeting. The *ONLY* complement on that first beer was that "you have the sanitization part down!". Everyone dumped it into a "dump bucket" in the middle of the basement where we were meeting!

      The next batch, made with a kit from Northern Brewer rather than an old canned wort kit from a local shop, was significantly fresher and better. But tasting what the other brewers were making encouraged me to just dive into all-grain. I turned a used cooler into a mash tun, either got Northern Brewer to mill the grain in the kit for me, or got a friend with a mill nearby to mill it for me, and went all grain with batch #3. At some point later I got my own mill, and started buying full 55 pound sacks of base malt at a local brewery, and I just order hops, yeast and specialty malt online now.

      Not having a basement (ideal place to ferment), I use an old upright fridge someone gave me with a temp controller to control my fermentation temperature.

      I've brewed at most 5-6 kegs of beer this year, and am not running through it like I did when we had more get-togethers with friends and kids, but I try to keep 4 kegs on tap in the garage. There are years my brew log shows I have brewed 15 to 20 kegs, but those were the years I brewed for weddings.

      Comment


        #12
        Thank you jfmorris for that thorough explanation! I'm sure I'll be reading and re-reading this several times! So it sounds like, if I have a way to control temperature, like an old fridge or insulated cabinet, I should be ok to set this up in the garage. That's going to be a relief to my wife! My only challenge is going to be getting the space I'll need, as I've got quite a few things in the garage already. I may have to think about rebuilding my shed sooner than I had first thought.

        Edit: What kind of temperature control are you using with the fridge?

        Comment


        • jfmorris
          jfmorris commented
          Editing a comment
          I understand the space challenge! See my answer on temp control below. I ferment in an old 15 to 18 cubic foot top-freezer fridge someone gave me for free.

        #13
        dpearce this is what I use today for temperature control during fermentation:



        The refrigerator itself plugs into the "cooling" outlet on the controller, which hangs on the wall next to the fridge. I put a bungie strap around my fermenter with a rag or wad of bubble wrap and put the sensor under it (to insulate it from the air in the fridge), and just let that wire go under the door seal of the fridge. That is all I need in summer.

        In cold weather, out in the garage, it can be cooler than the typical 68F fermentation temp, and I add one of these to the fridge, just loosely sitting around the back of the fermenter, not necessarily tightly up to it:



        And once again, I just run that cord out the door seal and plug it in the heating outlet on the controller. It kicks on when needed to keep the beer warm and within a degree of the set point.

        When not fermenting in that fridge, it is just my beer and wine fridge, and space for brisket or the thanksgiving turkey.

        Comment


          #14
          This Saturday, I took a few minutes and stopped by Buckeye Brewers, which is surprisingly, not far from my house.

          A couple weeks ago, after talking with you guys, I stopped in and told them about the stuff I was given, and a very nice young lady there was able to answer my questions, and in her opinion, what she would buy versus reuse in the equipment I was given. After looking over all their stuff (wasn't hard, it's a one room showroom) and adding up everything in my head, I realized I'd be less than $60-$70 in on what I would need, which would include a beer kit.

          So, after cataloging exactly what I thought I would need, I went back on Saturday, and believe it or not, they were having an open house with a local brew club in attendance. I got to taste some great brew, see some really interesting setups, and once they found out I was new to the game, had all sorts of recommendations and advice. Super friendly people!

          They invited me to their club meeting, as well. They remind me of almost everyone I've ever met who brewed their own. Just nice guys who are passionate about their craft. I had so much to do that day, I had to tear myself away, but it was difficult. It smelled soooo gooood!

          So I got some lids for the fermentation stage (my boss was missing those), Star San (bought that the first time I visited), some "bubblers" and some assorted plastic tubing, some new carboy stoppers, and a brew kit.

          Here's the kit:

          Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_6556.jpg Views:	0 Size:	3.01 MB ID:	1900214

          I was carrying this around at the parking lot at the open house, and a couple guys actually complimented me, and said, "hey this is a pretty decent kit to start with". So that made me feel a little better about my choice.

          So one fellow I was talking with, Chris, when I mentioned the logistics of fermenting in the garage versus a basement, said he typically boils his water outside, and then moves it into his basement for fermentation. I had told him I have a finished area in the basement, that maintains a constant 68 degrees, and he agreed, that's optimal for most of his brewing, and certainly ok for this kit. So I think with this go-round, I'll plan on boiling the water in the garage, then cooling it, and transporting it down to the basement for fermenting. As much as I would love to avoid the steps, carrying stuff around, at this point, I'll deal with it.

          The next steps I have to figure out. Those guys had kegs and carbonation set up, and a lot of them skip step two, go right into a keg and carbonation control, then wait out the finished product. I have the fridge for that, but not the keg or carbonation, so I may (might) be doing a second stage, then possibly bottling, which I really think due to the amount of sanitizing and bottling, I would rather do the "straight to keg". More research is needed on my part before I start this process, because I think this will result in more purchases. I'm not against that, I ain't about washing 52-54 beer bottles and capping them. Regardless, before I start anything, I'll need to decide how I'm handling this part of the process.

          Oh, speaking of cooling! Man, every one of the setups I saw had a copper cooling coil. I'm handy enough, and have soldering tools, I may just make my own cooling coil. Chris said it was soooo much better than dealing with a hot pot and an ice bath. Timewise, he agreed it would definitely be faster. So that's on my list.

          So we'll see how this first batch goes. I'll post here on this thread when I fire it off, and try to document it.

          Also, I was able to obtain a copy of How to Brew, by John J. Palmer. Thank you for the info!

          And Thanksgiving is coming up so, I might be distracted by a turkey and family. Mostly by family... hmph.
          Last edited by dpearce; November 8, 2026, 10:28 PM.

          Comment


          • Waster
            Waster commented
            Editing a comment
            Some great advice from on here (especially @jfmorris) and from those club members.
            If I were you as you are boiling on one area and transferring to another, I would look into the no-chill method - this is where you do not need a coil, ice, pump etc and transfer hot wort straight into fermenter and allow to cool to pitching temp. You will of course need a fermenter capable of handling the high initial temp of the wort. But you could cool it before transporting and be a lot safer - I do this

          • WI Bubba
            WI Bubba commented
            Editing a comment
            Sounds like you're heading in the right direction! I highly recommend getting/making a cooling coil just for the time they save. I've seen two of the in series with each other with stage one sitting in a bucket of ice water so that the water was really cold when when it went through the coil in the brew pot. Seemed like a good idea, but I never got that fancy.

          #15
          dpearce asked me to explain what a conical fermenter is. However, before that, I would encourage you to go ahead and make a batch with a glass carboy since you already have one. The reason is because you can watch the fermentation process through the glass. I assume you already have a racking cane and tubing is cheap, so a one time shot will not only give you a front row seat to the fermentation, but also hands on experience as to why you don’t want to use a carboy. You will find them heavy and cumbersome (and slippery when wet). Siphoning is a PITA. Cleaning and sanitation isn’t a walk in the park with a carboy. You’ll discover all this when you use it, and after having seen the wort ferment a time or two you will have seen it enough to want an upgrade.

          i never used a plastic bucket to ferment in. At the risk of stepping on someone’s toes (I apologise in advance) the only advantage over a carboy is easier to clean and sanitise along with being lighter and less cumbersome. You will still need to siphon unless you install a valve above the yeast bed. By the biggest disadvantage is, IMO, is that plastic will scratch, and scratches are hard to impossible to sanitise.

          The ultimate solution is the conical fermenter. It is how commercial breweries, from micro to the big boys, ferment. At some point, some brilliant person scaled them down to size for home brewers, and the world become a better place.

          Here is what they look like along with their price ranges:

          Family-owned since 1995, MoreBeer! offers the industry's deepest selection of homebrewing gear. 8,000+ products, brewer-run support, and everything you need for your brew day.


          Now that you have gotten past the sticker shock, note what they all have in common. Basically, they are a pot, but instead of a flat bottom, the bottom funnels down into a cone. The yeast will settle into the cone. You’ll recall from your glass carboy fermentation show that when it was all over all the yeast settled to the bottom of the carboy, leaving the clear, finished beer above like oil and water.You siphoned out the clear beer (brewers call that ‘racking’) and left that yeast bed behind. A conical fermenter should have two valves, one at the very bottom of the cone and one slightly higher up. When the beer has fully fermented, a tube is attached to the upper valve and run into a collection container, which can be a secondary fermenter, a keg, or a bottling bucket. The yeast bed will remain in the bottom of the cone.

          With carboy fermenting, the yeast is generally dumped out. Trying to dump it into a freshly prepared carboy runs the risk of contamination. I imagine it is the same for a bottling bucket. But with the conical fermenter you can put a sanitised flask under the bottom valve and dump the yeast into it. You can seal it and set it aside while you clean the fermenter. I always brewed on the day I racked off the fermenter, so I would refill the fermenter with fresh wort and re-pitch the yeast from the flask.

          (Side note; when you brew you add yeast to the cooled wort to start the fermentation process. Beginners dump dry yeast because it is easy and cheap. The problem is that the yeast has to build up a population before it begins fermenting. This lag time can allow any bacteria that may have found its way into the fermenter to grow as well. More advanced brewers use liquid yeast which comes in a pouch. It has a head start and faster response. Even more advanced brewers have Erlenmeyer flasks (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erlenmeyer_flask) and ‘bump up’ the yeast before pitching. The greater the yeast population before pitching the faster it takes off . With the conical fermenter, you can grab the yeast from the previous batch and it is already to go, fermentation begins immediately. Side note to the side note; Erlenmeyer flasks are hard to come by in a decent size as they are used in illegal drug manufacturing. I had to jump through a lot of hoops to obtain mine.)

          Back to the fermenter. You no doubt have noticed that there is quite the price range. The cheaper ones are made of plastic, the most expensive stainless steel. Some come with temperature control systems. My recommendation would be to get a plastic one if that is all you can afford, it’s better than a plastic bucket. But if you can afford stainless steel, by all means get that. Temperature controls are an option, you can control the temperature of the room you are fermenting in. But they are nice if it is in your budget.

          Summed up, use what you have now, get some experience. Find out if it is something you want to or enjoy doing before investing. Start with extract brewing. It is the easiest and for many enough for them. Don’t let grain brewers try to tell you aren’t really brewing. Once you know brewing is for you and grain sings its siren song, then ftake the plunge. Sort of like the BBQ world, start with a cheap charcoal grill, build your way up to that fancy stick burner.

          i hope that helps, any specific questions, feel free to ask.
          Last edited by ComfortablyNumb; November 9, 2026, 08:33 AM.

          Comment


          • dpearce
            dpearce commented
            Editing a comment
            ComfortablyNumb Thank you! Lots of good information, much appreciated! I will make sure I refer back to this as things progress.

        Announcement

        Collapse
        No announcement yet.
        Working...
        X
        false
        0
        Guest
        Guest
        500
        ["membership","help","nojs","maintenance","shop","reset-password","authaau-alpha","ebooklogin-start","alpha","start"]
        false
        false
        Yes
        ["\/forum\/free-deep-dive-guide-ebook-downloads","\/forum\/free-deep-dive-guide-ebook-downloads\/1157845-paid-members-download-your-6-deep-dive-guide-ebooks-for-free-here","\/forum\/the-pitcast","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/bbq-news-magazine-2019-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/bbq-news-magazine-2020-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/bbq-news-magazine-2021-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/bbq-news-magazine-2022-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/current-2023-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/current-2024-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/current-2025-issues","\/forum\/national-barbecue-news-magazine\/national-barbecue-news-magazine-aa\/current-2026-issues","\/forum\/bbq-stars","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/tuffy-stone","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/meathead","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/harry-soo","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/matt-pittman","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/kent-rollins","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/dean-fearing","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/tim-grandinetti","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/kent-phillips-brett-gallaway","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/david-bouska","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/ariane-daguin","\/forum\/bbq-stars\/jack-arnold","\/forum\/free-deep-dive-guide-ebook-downloads"]
        /forum/free-deep-dive-guide-ebook-downloads
        7