I apologize if this question has been previously answered 5,000 time (I did read the existing info on free site, etc.).
When grilling a thick beef steak, what is the drawback to initially searing it and then moving it to lower indirect heat? Seems that working in that order would allow the steak’s internal temp to be more readily monitored. Thanks!
The main advantage is that if you slow cook first, the surface is dry and your sear is faster so the sear affects the internal temperature even less. The front sear takes longer because of evaporating moisture before you get the Malliard reaction. This can create an over cooked layer under the crust.
Not sure why any cooking approach would impact your ability to properly monitor the internal temp. The reverse sear approach generally results in a better sear and a smaller gray band of overcooked meat between the medium rare (or whatever) center and the surface of the meat
If it's at all on the thin side I'll front sear. Like these elk steaks from last night were tiny. There was no way I was going to reverse sear these. If it's thick I'll usually reverse sear. Either way works fine though. Do what works for you.
Weber Performer, Weber Jumbo Joe, Weber Smokey Joe (which I made into a mini-WSM), Weber Q 120 (which I converted to a portable flat top griddle), Oklahoma Joe offset cabinet smoker, Lodge hibachi, Pitt Boss Tailgater
Maverick ET 733
Favorite Cook - Sausage, any kind of sausage!
Watched Michael Symon test an idea that someone sent to him, searing a frozen steak in a screaming hot iron skillet. I know that to some freezing a steak is sacrilege and I don't plan to get into that debate, however I did try the same thing but using my weber smokey joe and a full load of charcoal. Let the charcoal get to max temp (with bottom and top vents wide open) before putting on a 1.25 inch CAB ribeye that I had frozen just for this test. Turned out wonderful, for me. I say "for me" because I like my steak extremely rare (some call it blue) and it is hard to get a steak that rare and still get a decent crust on the outside.
KenC52 Oddly enough tonight I was reading about grilling semi-frozen and dry-brined thin pork chops so they don’t overcook before picking up color and sear.
Not Cowboy Action Shooter, but I do own several lever action rifles and single action revolvers. Pic was taken in Hot Springs Ark. while on our honeymoon
Scotch: Current favorite- The Arran (anything by them), Glenmorangie 12yr Lasanta, sherry cask finished. The Balvenie Double Wood, also like Oban 18yr, and The Glenlivet Nadurra (Oloroso sherry cask finished) among others. Neat please.
About meReal name: Aaron
Location: Farwell, Michigan- near Clare. (dead center of lower peninsula)
Occupation:
Healthcare- Licensed & Registered Respiratory Therapist (RRT) at MyMichigan Health, a University of Michigan Health System.
I've switched a couple years ago to doing exactly what you're asking. It's called front sear. It's my method of choice for steaks & burgers. I sear to whatever level pleases me then slow cook indirectly up to my target temp. I personally feel I have better control over the final temp instead of zooming past it during a reverse sear.
I've had my last couple of reverse sear "cold grate" method steaks come out well done, when I was shooting for medium rare, all during the sear step. It was still tender as it was prime beef, but I will have to try the front sear next time.
You are making me think. Stop it. It hurts. I always worry about shooting past temp. Especially if my searing coals are not as hot as they should be and it takes a bit longer to get a crust.
My wife hers so rare that I wound not have time to reverse sear. So I don't do mine either. Don't notice a gray edge on my rare to med. rare steak. We usually only do ribeyes.
I always front sear, and my wife sez I am now making the best steaks ever. I flip every minute after an overnight and uncovered dry brine. I don't take the steaks out of the refrigerator until the grill is hot.
Reverse searing leads to greater carry over cooking than a front sear. That makes it harder to hit your target temp - well, at least for me. The temp rise during the hot n fast portion is much quicker, so I do that first while the steak is still cold so it will have less effect on the inside of the meat.
AT least that's my story and I'm stickin' to it...
Side note: The beauty of this place is you can ask a question that's been asked 5001 times and no one get's their pantaloons in a bunch. We'll just answer your question. Or say something silly so no apology neccessary.
Front vs reverse depends on the meat thickness for me. I do thin stuff front and thick stuff reverse. (Admittedly, the cuts I front sear only get seared.) Most pro-reverse guides tend to state the technique requires thick cuts.
I’m actually surprised to see a lot of regulars preferring front searing. I’ve never had an issue with carryover when reversing. I tend to let the meat rest before the sear though. A lot of videos show people getting the coals heated before the steaks come to temp. I take some of the hot coals from the slow cook to start the fire for the hot stuff so I don’t start my fire till I take the steaks out of the cooker.
This brings me to another point, it’s easier to start a cook at a lower temperature and switch to inferno in my opinion. If you’re using one cooker and running charcoal, reverse is very convenient. This is probably more of a driving factor than anything else.
Cold, wet meat takes on smoke better. So if you’re smoking during the slow stage, in my experience, reverse picks up smoke flavoring better. This is, by far, my favorite way to do a steak.
I also sous-vide a lot which pretty much requires reverse searing if you want a crust.
Time to rest before searing and how long you sear in front vs reverse will also affect things differently. I typically only sear 2 minutes on each side flipping every minute. By the time the meat is heated and patted dry, it won’t take much to finish it.
Last edited by binarypaladin; August 10, 2019, 08:13 PM.
What he said. The wait/hold before searing is crucial in my opinion. I call it "wait for the dip" (1 deg down in temp). When that happens I know the steak is ready to sear.
Nice to hear a kind of hard rule to fall back on. I've never really measured. It's nice to pull the steaks off and know I have time to finish the potatoes and veggies or whatever. (Or wait for late guests, lol.) I'm not even overly strict with my sear times. It's about a minute per side, but I'll add 30 seconds here or there until I like the look of the crust.
When my wife cooks steak up to about and inch and a half thick she sears in a cast iron skillet and then finishes in the oven. They turn out fantastic. Anything larger and we go for reverse sear.
Same with my wife - small splash of olive oil in the pan, simmers fresh cut thyme and rosemary in the pan, removes the stems and proceeds as you describe.
Weber S-335 gas grill
Weber 26†kettle
Weber 22†kettle
Camp Chef XL Smoke Vault
Camp Chef 3 Burner cook top
Camp Chef Woodwind 36 Pellet grill with sidekick burner
PBC
Accessories:
SnS XL
SnS standard
Vortex
Weber Rotisserie for 22†Kettle
1st gen FireBoard
2nd gen FireBoard
Griddle for Camp Chef cooktop
Several Thermoworks items
Set of Grill Grates
I have found front searing seems to be what everyone in our family likes best. Not to say a reverse sear isn't great also but we seem to prefer the front sear best. Plus it seems to fit my equipment better also. I like using my 26" weber. I'll buy 4-2"+ thick ribeyes, fill a chimney 3/4 full and get it going as hot as I can. Then set a grate directly on the chimney, then sear each steak one at a time. Once all the steaks are seared on all sides I dump the coals in my slow n sear with a few extra unlit coals and a chunk of wood. Now is when i season the meat so it doesn't burn. Then set the steaks on the indirect side and let them go until 125-130 internal.
Front sear.....never heard this term before, but this the way I always grill my steaks, Tri-Tip, prime rib. As mentioned by others, I feel I have better control. Especially with TT. Get the caramelization I want ( on the front end), then move it over to finish indirect. I’ve never done a reverse sear.
Comment